Canberra admits the risk before it writes the law
Australia's government wants to let AI companies scrape copyrighted material to train their models. Before the bill exists, the attorney-general's department has already said, on the record, that it is "extremely alive" to the possibility that doing this could breach the constitution.
That phrase is doing real work. Section 51(xxxi) of the Australian constitution bars the Commonwealth from acquiring property except on "just terms" — the same provision that has been used before against laws reaching into native title and intellectual property. If a scraping permission strips rights holders of the practical value of their copyright without compensation, a court could treat that as an acquisition requiring payment, not a mere regulatory limit. This is not a fringe reading of the constitution; it is the reading that has previously forced governments to pay for laws they thought were free.
The Guardian reports that Coalition senators, the recording industry, and constitutional expert Anne Twomey are the ones pressing this argument publicly, warning the changes could trigger compensation claims from rights holders around the world. The attorney-general's department's response, as reported, isn't a denial and isn't a defence. It's an acknowledgment that the risk is being weighed as the legislation is drafted — nothing more, nothing less. I'd resist reading it as either a concession that the plan is doomed or a bureaucratic brush-off; it's a department saying, in effect, that this is one of the live variables in how the clause gets written.
What I don't have is the clause itself. Nothing in what I've read names whether the carve-out would work as an opt-out for rights holders, a statutory licence with built-in payment, or a flat permission with no compensation mechanism at all. That distinction is the whole ballgame constitutionally — a scheme with compensation built in has a much weaker claim against it than one without. Until the actual drafting is public, what exists is a warning and an acknowledgment that the warning is being taken seriously. Not yet a law to judge.