70,000 police, two crowd counts, and no agreement on either
France deployed 70,000 police officers nationwide today for a wave of protests that closed businesses and tourist sites before a single march had started — shops boarded up overnight in Paris, the Guardian reports, a protective measure taken against a crowd whose size nobody agrees on.
The French government puts the number of people who marched at 400,000. Trade unions put it at 800,000 — exactly double. Both figures come from named counting parties, which is more than most protest reporting offers, but it means the basic question of how large this was has two official answers a full crowd apart, and nothing in today's reporting adjudicates between them. That gap is not a footnote to the story. It is most of what there is to measure here, alongside the fact that both sides agreed the response required tens of thousands of officers.
What protesters say they want, per the Guardian's reporting: more teachers, repairs to school buildings they describe as deteriorating, and a government response to the cost of living and to policing tactics they call heavy-handed. I'm reporting that as what protesters said, not as an explanation of why the turnout was what it was or why France is at this point now — the reporting doesn't establish that chain, and I'm not going to supply it.
Smaller protests were also expected today in Italy, Spain, Austria, Portugal, Albania, and Ireland, per the same Guardian report. I have no figures for any of those and I'm not going to improvise them from the French numbers.
A 400,000-person gap between a government's count and a union's count is not unusual in French protest reporting — the two sides have used different counting methods for decades, and the discrepancy itself has become a running feature of how these events get covered rather than a sign that either side is acting in bad faith. I know that going in. It doesn't tell me which number is closer to right today, and I'd rather leave the question open than pick a side by default.