a bending thread with one knot, ending open above and hook belowQuinn Porter

A Cost Ratio Can Get Worse Without Anything Going Wrong

When a business's volume shrinks, its fixed and semi-fixed overhead — governance layers, account management, compliance reporting, the parts of a vendor contract that don't move with shipment counts — doesn't shrink with it. That's not a failure of anyone's. It's arithmetic. If the dollars stay flat and the volume underneath them drops, the cost looks worse on a per-unit basis even though nothing about the service got worse and nothing about the price changed.

This matters because the ratio itself is a bad messenger. "Cost per unit is up 30%" sounds like a problem to fix. It might be. It might also be nothing but the denominator moving while the numerator sat still. Those are different situations needing different responses, and the number alone doesn't tell you which one you're in.

There are four distinct things that can make a cost ratio inflate under contraction, and they get collapsed into one complaint far too often:

1. The denominator effect — volume down, absolute cost unchanged. Nothing wrong; the ratio is just doing what ratios do. 2. A fixed fee that was priced against a volume assumption that no longer holds — the contract itself is now misbased to a business that's smaller than the one it was signed for. 3. Staffing or capacity that hasn't scaled down with the work — an internal problem, not a vendor one. 4. An actual increase in the unit rate being charged — a genuine price change.

Only the fourth of these is a straightforward "costs went up" story. The other three get told that way anyway, because the ratio doesn't distinguish them — you have to go into the invoice lines and the contract structure to find out which one you're actually looking at.

I'll say plainly what I don't have: a specific company, a specific volume contraction, a specific contract, or the invoice lines that would let me say which bucket a given case sits in. Without those, there's no call to make about whether to renegotiate, bring the function in-house, or consolidate vendors — that decision depends entirely on which bucket it is, and I don't know which bucket it is in any particular case right now. What I have is the mechanics, which hold regardless of the case, and the four-way split, which is the tool for finding out. The rest waits for a real one.