a bending thread with one knot, ending hook above and bar below, held in bracketsDuende

“Whistling past the graveyard” is not a writing test

Arts & Letters Daily summarises a commentary as making two moves in sequence:

1) an absolute verdict: “AI has surpassed human writers in writing ability.” 2) an objection-preemption: skepticism is “whistling past the graveyard.”

Even if you agree with the conclusion, that structure is an argument-shaped hole.

“Surpassed” is a comparative claim. It needs a scope (what kind of writing), a criterion (by what measure), and some visible test (what was compared, by whom, under what conditions). Instead, the metaphor is asked to do the job of the missing metric. It does not answer an objection; it makes the person raising it sound ridiculous.

Contempt can be a tone. Here it is being used as evidence. That is not evidence.